6 Best Alternatives to the New Classic Home Furnishings Classic Furniture Gia 5-Piece (2026)

How these alternatives compare

Ashley D425-223 Round Counter Height Set

The Signature Design by Ashley set keeps the same round counter height footprint as the New Classic Gia, measuring 42 inches wide and 36.3 inches high. It matches the Gia’s 130-pound weight closely at 134 pounds. The key difference is the grey finish instead of ebony. This option appeals if you prefer a lighter color palette for your kitchen. It offers similar space-saving benefits for small areas. The construction focuses on practical storage and durability. You get a comparable seating capacity for four. The design remains compact and functional. This set serves as a direct visual alternative with a neutral tone. It maintains the sturdy build quality expected in this category. The dimensions ensure it fits standard small dining layouts just as well as the original model.

New Classic Mitchell 5-Piece Counter Set

The New Classic Mitchell set shares the brand’s construction style but shifts to a cherry brown finish. It measures 42 inches wide and 36 inches high, slightly shorter than the Gia’s 36.3 inches. This set weighs only 75 pounds, making it significantly lighter and easier to move. The solid rubber wood frame and padded chairs provide familiar comfort. The round 42-inch surface offers the same seating for four. This model suits buyers who prioritize lightweight portability without sacrificing durability. The single-box shipping simplifies delivery. The cherry brown tone adds warmth compared to the ebony finish. It retains the compact footprint ideal for small kitchens. The lower weight makes it a practical choice for frequent rearranging. You get a trusted brand build with a different aesthetic and easier handling.

New Classic Amy Counter Dining Set

The New Classic Amy set mirrors the Gia’s dimensions with a 42-inch width and 36-inch height. It also weighs 130 pounds, matching the original’s heft. The grey veneer top offers a modern contrast to the ebony finish. This set emphasizes stability and a compact round design. The solid weight capacity ensures durable use for four people. The veneer top provides a smooth, easy-to-clean surface. It fits small kitchens where space is at a premium. The grey color scheme appeals to contemporary decor preferences. The construction remains sturdy and reliable. You get the same brand quality with a updated look. The set maintains the counter height utility while offering a sleeker visual profile. It is a solid choice for those who want familiar specs with a fresh color option.

Best Choice Products Round Counter Dining Set

The Best Choice Products set stands out with a smaller 35.5-inch diameter table, compared to the Gia’s 42 inches. It measures 37 inches high, slightly taller than the Gia’s 36.3 inches. This set weighs 81.7 pounds, much lighter than the original. The natural finish offers a bright, modern aesthetic. It prioritizes easy cleaning and high chair weight limits over a larger table surface. The compact size suits small modern dining spaces where every inch counts. You get a sturdy option that fits tighter corners. The modern style appeals to minimalist decor. The reduced table size means less dining area but easier maneuverability. This set is ideal if you value a sleek, lightweight design over maximum surface space. It offers a distinct alternative for smaller footprints.

Steve Silver Joanna 7pc Round Counter Set

The Steve Silver Joanna set expands your options with a 59.5-inch diameter table, significantly larger than the Gia’s 42 inches. It maintains a similar 36.3-inch height. This set weighs 99 pounds, lighter than the Gia. The farmhouse style offers a traditional look distinct from the Gia’s modern ebony finish. It provides ample seating and expandable surface area for family meals. The multi-colored finish adds visual interest. This model suits households needing flexible dining space and traditional decor. The larger table accommodates more guests comfortably. You get a robust farmhouse aesthetic with practical seating. The set is ideal for those who need more room than the compact Gia offers. It balances size and weight while delivering a classic dining experience. The expandable feature adds versatility for larger gatherings.

Lexicon 5-Piece Counter Height Dining Set

The Lexicon set matches the Gia’s 42-inch width and 36.5-inch height closely. It weighs 127 pounds, nearly identical to the original. The brown and black color scheme offers a distinct visual contrast. This set includes a useful storage shelf under the table, a feature absent in the Gia. The sturdy round table provides reliable seating for four. The wood material ensures durability. It fits small kitchens where counter height and extra storage matter. The storage shelf adds practical utility for dining essentials. You get a functional design that maximizes space efficiency. The set appeals to buyers who need additional storage without sacrificing seating. The construction remains solid and stable. This model offers a practical advantage for organized dining areas. It combines familiar dimensions with added convenience.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

New Classic Gia 5-Piece Ebony Set

Best for: small dining areas needing four seats

Number of Pieces

5

Seating Capacity

4

Table Shape

round

Height Type

counter height

Table Material

Mindi wood veneers, solid rubber wood

Chair Material

solid wood, black faux leather

View on Amazon: New Classic Gia 5-Piece Ebony Set Affiliate link

This New Classic Furniture Gia set includes a round counter-height table and four chairs. The table measures 42.3 inches wide and 36.3 inches high. It is built from Mindi wood veneers and solid rubber wood. The chairs feature padded backs and seats upholstered in black faux leather. Each chair supports up to 250 pounds. This set suits you if you need a durable dining area for four people.

Pros

• Round table top with reverse diamond match veneer
• Chairs have padded seats and backs
• Solid wood frame construction
• 250 lbs weight limit per chair

Cons

• Only one year limited warranty
• Requires assembly
• Table is 42.3 inches wide

Good fit if

• You want a round table shape
• You need counter-height seating
• You prefer black faux leather upholstery

Skip if

• You need a dining set for more than four people
• You prefer a standard height table
• You want a pre-assembled unit

Verdict: New Classic Gia 5-Piece Ebony Set offers solid construction with padded chairs and a round table. It fits small spaces where you need four seats at counter height.

2 Also great

Ashley D425-223 Round Counter Height Set

Best for: small kitchens needing counter height seating

Number of Pieces

5

Seating Capacity

4

Table Shape

round

Height Type

counter height

Table Material

Rubberwood solids, mindi veneer, MDF

Chair Material

Solid wood, engineered wood, polyester

View on Amazon: Ashley D425-223 Round Counter Height Set Affiliate link

This Signature Design by Ashley set offers a round counter height table with four matching stools. The table measures 42 inches wide and 36.3 inches high, featuring a gray finish and discreet under-table storage shelves. The stools have a 24-inch seat height and textured upholstery. It seats four people comfortably in a kitchen nook or dining room.

Pros

• Round table shape saves corner space
• Includes discreet storage shelves under the table
• Counter height design suits kitchen nooks
• Transitional gray style with textured upholstery

Cons

• Assembly required with screwdriver needed
• Heavier build at 134 pounds
• Limited to four seating capacity

Good fit if

• You need a compact round table for small spaces
• You want integrated storage under the table
• You prefer counter height seating

Skip if

• You need seating for more than four people
• You want a pre-assembled product
• You prefer a rectangular table shape

Verdict: Ashley Round Counter Height Dining Set fits buyers who value space-saving round designs and built-in storage. It is a practical option for small kitchens needing counter height seating for four.

3 Also great

New Classic Mitchell 5-Piece Counter Set

Best for: small kitchens needing round counter-height seating

Number of Pieces

5

Seating Capacity

4

Table Shape

Round

Height Type

Counter Height

Table Material

Mindi Wood Veneers and Solid Rubber Wood

Table Dimensions

42" L x 42" W x 36" H

View on Amazon: New Classic Mitchell 5-Piece Counter Set Affiliate link

This New Classic Furniture Mitchell set includes one round counter-height table and four matching chairs. The table top uses reverse diamond match veneer over solid rubber wood, while the chairs feature solid wood frames with padded seats and backs. The 42-inch round table seats four people comfortably. Each chair supports up to 250 pounds. The set ships in a single box with included hardware and instructions.

Pros

• Round table top with reverse diamond match veneer
• Chairs have padded seats and backs for comfort
• 250 lbs weight capacity per chair
• Solid rubber wood construction for durability
• Ships in one convenient box

Cons

• 1-year limited warranty is shorter than industry standards
• Requires assembly despite single-box shipping
• No app or smart features included

Good fit if

• You need a sturdy round table for four
• You prefer traditional cherry brown finishes
• You want padded seating for long meals

Skip if

• You need a standard height dining set
• You require a warranty longer than one year
• You prefer a square or rectangular table shape

Verdict: New Classic Mitchell 5-Piece Counter Set offers solid rubber wood construction and padded chairs for comfortable dining. It fits small spaces well due to its round 42-inch footprint and single-box shipping.

4 Also great

New Classic Amy Counter Dining Set

Best for: Small kitchens needing sturdy round seating

Number of Pieces

5

Height Type

Counter Height

Table Material

Mindi, Rubber Wood Solids and Veneers

Chair Material

Padded

Table Dimensions

42.25" L x 42.25" W x 36.25" H

Weight Capacity per Chair

250 lbs

View on Amazon: New Classic Amy Counter Dining Set Affiliate link

The New Classic Furniture Amy 5-piece set features a round counter-height table and four padded chairs. The table top uses reverse diamond match veneer on Mindi and rubber wood solids. Each chair supports 250 lbs. The gray finish fits modern decor. This set suits small kitchens needing sturdy, stylish seating for four.

Pros

• Round table measures 42.25 inches wide
• Chairs support 250 lbs each
• Padded seat cushions for comfort
• Durable Mindi and rubber wood construction

Cons

• Heavy at 130 pounds total
• Limited color options available
• Requires assembly

Good fit if

• You need a sturdy round table for four
• You prefer counter-height seating
• You want a gray modern look

Skip if

• You need a dining table for more than four people
• You prefer a standard height table
• You want a lightweight set for easy moving

Verdict: The New Classic Furniture Amy Gray Counter Set offers solid weight capacity and a durable veneer top for small spaces. It fits buyers who value stability and a compact round design.

5 Best budget

Best Choice Products Round Counter Dining Set

Best for: small modern dining spaces

Number of Pieces

5

Table Shape

Round

Height Type

Counter height

Table Material

MDF, steel

Chair Material

MDF, steel

Table Dimensions

35.5"(Dia) x 37"(H)

View on Amazon: Best Choice Products Round Counter Dining Set Affiliate link

This 5-piece counter height set features a 35.5-inch round table and four chairs. The MDF surfaces are coated in PVC for easy cleaning. Steel frames provide sturdy support. The table holds 175 pounds, while each chair supports up to 275 pounds. It fits four people comfortably. The natural finish and modern design suit contemporary dining rooms. You get a complete set in two boxes.

Pros

• Counter height design with 37-inch table
• Round 35.5-inch diameter table top
• PVC coating for easy maintenance
• 275-pound weight capacity per chair
• Steel frame construction for stability

Cons

• 35.5-inch table is smaller than standard 39-inch options
• 175-pound table weight limit is modest
• Ships in two separate boxes

Good fit if

• You want a compact round table for small spaces
• You prefer easy-to-clean PVC surfaces
• You need sturdy chairs with high weight limits

Skip if

• You require a larger 39-inch or bigger table
• You need a single-box delivery
• You prefer solid wood over MDF construction

Verdict: Best Choice Products 5-Piece Modern Dining Set offers a compact, sturdy option for small dining areas. It suits you if you prioritize easy cleaning and high chair weight limits over a larger table surface.

6 Best premium

Steve Silver Joanna 7pc Round Counter Set

Best for: expanding dining capacity in farmhouse kitchens

Number of Pieces

7

Seating Capacity

6

Table Shape

Round

Height Type

Counter Height

Table Dimensions

42" L x 42" W x 36.25" H

Style

Farmhouse

View on Amazon: Steve Silver Joanna 7pc Round Counter Set Affiliate link

This Steve Silver Joanna set offers seven pieces for counter-height dining. It features a round table with a 42-inch diameter that expands to 59.5 inches using double-drop leaves. The built-in lazy susan aids serving. The design fits farmhouse aesthetics. It seats six people comfortably. This set suits those needing flexible space and traditional style.

Pros

• Includes 7 total pieces for group dining
• Double-drop leaves expand table width to 59.5 inches
• Built-in lazy susan for easy serving
• Farmhouse style design

Cons

• Heavier at 99 pounds, making it less portable
• Multi-colored finish may not match all decor schemes
• Limited to counter height, not standard or bar height

Good fit if

• You need extra seating for up to six guests
• You want a table that expands for larger gatherings
• You prefer a farmhouse style with functional storage

Skip if

• You require a standard height table
• You need a lightweight set for frequent moving
• You prefer a solid, non-expanding table surface

Verdict: Steve Silver Joanna 7pc Farmhouse Set provides ample seating and expandable surface area for family meals. It is ideal for households that value flexible dining space and traditional decor.

7 Best 4

Lexicon 5-Piece Counter Height Dining Set

Best for: small kitchens needing counter height and storage

Number of Pieces

5

Seating Capacity

4

Table Shape

round

Height Type

counter height

Table Material

acacia veneer, engineered wood

Backrest Style

cross-back

View on Amazon: Lexicon 5-Piece Counter Height Dining Set Affiliate link

This Lexicon set includes a round counter-height table and four chairs. The table measures 42 inches in diameter and stands 36.5 inches tall. It features a fixed open shelf for storage. The construction uses acacia veneer and engineered wood. The design combines a brown wood grain top with a black base. It seats four people comfortably in a dining room or kitchen area.

Pros

• Round table is 42 inches in diameter
• Built-in fixed open storage shelf
• Acacia veneer and engineered wood build
• 250 lbs weight capacity per seat

Cons

• Screwdriver not included for assembly
• Only a 1-year limited warranty
• No remote or app control available

Good fit if

• You need a counter-height table for four people
• You want built-in storage under the table
• You prefer a round table shape

Skip if

• You require a standard height dining table
• You need a rectangular table shape
• You want a tool-free assembly process

Verdict: Lexicon 5-Piece Counter Height Dining Set offers a sturdy round table with a useful storage shelf. It fits small kitchens where counter height and extra storage matter.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions

See also

• tama superstar classic cl52ks 5 piece alternatives
• best 5-Piece cookware sets