New Classic Home Furnishings Classic Furniture Mitchell 5-Piece vs New Classic Home Furnishings Classic Furniture Amy 5-Piece Counter Dining Table Set (2026): Key Differences
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
You are looking at the new classic home furnishings classic furniture mitchell 5 piece vs the Amy 5-Piece Counter Dining Table Set. Both sets include five pieces: one table and four chairs. They share a gray finish and padded seats. The main difference is height and shape. The Mitchell is a standard-height round table. The Amy is a counter-height square table. Your choice depends on your room layout and preferred seating height.
Key differences
| Aspect | New Classic Mitchell 47" Round Dining Set | New Classic Amy Counter Dining Set |
|---|---|---|
| Height Type | Standard Height | Counter Height |
| Table Shape | Round | Square |
| Table Dimensions | 47" diameter x 30.25"H | 42.25"L x 42.25"W x 36.25"H |
| Chair Dimensions | Not listed | 18.5"L x 19.25"W x 40.25"H |
| Weight | 68.3 pounds | 130 pounds |
Which one should you choose?
Choose New Classic Mitchell 47" Round Dining Set if
- You prefer a round table that fits into corners or open spaces.
- You want standard dining height for comfortable legroom.
- You need a lighter set that is easier to move.
Choose New Classic Amy Counter Dining Set if
- You want a counter-height setup for a kitchen island.
- You prefer a square table shape for a modern look.
- You have taller chairs or stools to match the height.
Verdict: Choose the Mitchell if you want a classic round table at standard height. Pick the Amy if you need counter-height seating for a kitchen island. Both offer similar materials and weight limits.
Mitchell vs Amy Dining Set Specs
Number of Pieces
Both the New Classic Mitchell and the New Classic Amy sets are five-piece dining sets. Each includes one table and four matching chairs. This configuration provides seating for four people, which is standard for small to medium dining areas. You get the same number of items in the box regardless of which model you choose. The total piece count is identical, so you do not need to worry about missing chairs or extra tables. Both sets are designed to function as complete units for your kitchen or dining room.
Seating Capacity
Each set is designed to seat four people comfortably. The Mitchell set includes four padded chairs that match the gray finish of the table. Similarly, the Amy set comes with four chairs that coordinate with its table. Both sets have a weight limit of 250 pounds per chair, ensuring sturdy support for adult users. The seating capacity is identical across both models, meaning you will have the same number of spots for meals or gatherings. There is no difference in how many people can sit at the table at once.
Table Shape
The Mitchell set features a round table with a 47-inch diameter. This shape promotes conversation and allows for easier movement around the table. The Amy set also offers a round table, but the standard counter-height version has a 42.25-inch diameter. While both are round, the Mitchell table is slightly wider, providing more surface area for dining. The round shape in both cases maximizes seating efficiency in smaller rooms. You get the same geometric form, though the exact footprint differs slightly between the two models.
Height Type
The primary difference lies in the height. The Mitchell set is a standard dining height, with the table standing at 30.25 inches high. The Amy set is available in a counter-height version, where the table is 36.25 inches high. Counter-height tables pair with taller chairs, which can be more comfortable for some users. The Mitchell set is better for traditional dining room chairs, while the Amy counter set suits kitchen islands or higher counters. You should choose based on your existing counter or table height preferences.
Material Build
Both sets use high-quality materials for durability. The Mitchell table is crafted from Mindi wood veneers and solid rubber wood. The chairs are made of solid wood with padded seats and backs in light gray polyester fabric. The Amy set also uses Mindi wood, rubber wood solids, and veneers for the table. The chairs are padded, matching the luxurious feel of the Mitchell set. Both prioritize long-lasting furniture construction. You get similar material quality in both sets, with solid wood components and veneer tops for a refined look.
Which dining set fits your space
Standard height preference
Choose the Mitchell if you prefer standard table height. Its 30.25-inch height suits most dining chairs and knees. The 47-inch round top offers ample space for four people. Solid rubber wood construction supports a 250-pound weight limit per chair. This set fits well in rooms with standard ceiling clearance and traditional layouts.
Counter height preference
Select the Amy if you need counter height. The 36.25-inch table height matches standard kitchen counters. The square 42.25-inch top saves floor space in compact areas. Padded chairs provide comfort at a higher seating level. This set works best with bar stools or taller chairs for a modern kitchen island setup.
Lightweight moving needs
Pick the Mitchell for easier handling. It weighs 68.3 pounds, making it lighter than the Amy. The single-box shipping simplifies delivery and assembly. Mindi wood veneers and solid rubber wood provide durability without excessive mass. You get a complete five-piece set that is simpler to move into tight spaces or upstairs apartments.
The products compared
New Classic Mitchell 47" Round Dining Set
Best for: small kitchens needing a compact 4-chair set
- Number of Pieces
- 5
- Seating Capacity
- 4
- Table Material
- Mindi wood veneers, solid rubber wood
- Chair Material
- Solid wood, polyester fabric
- Backrest Style
- Padded
- Table Dimensions
- 47" diameter x 30.25"H
View on Amazon: New Classic Mitchell 47" Round Dining Set Affiliate link
This 5-piece dining set includes one 47-inch round table and four padded chairs. The table top features a reverse diamond match veneer, while the chairs use solid wood frames with light gray polyester upholstery. Each chair supports up to 250 lbs. The set ships in a single box with included hardware. It suits small kitchens or dining nooks needing a compact, coordinated gray finish.
Pros
- 47-inch diameter table top with reverse diamond match veneer
- Chairs feature padded seats and backs in polyester fabric
- 250 lbs weight limit per chair
- Ships in one convenient box with included instructions
Cons
- Only 4 chairs included for a 5-piece set
- 1-year limited warranty against manufacturer defects
- Requires assembly with included hardware
Good fit if
- You need a compact 47-inch round table for small spaces
- You prefer upholstered padded chairs for comfort
- You want a coordinated gray finish for your dining area
Skip if
- You require seating for more than 4 people
- You need a counter-height table (this is standard height)
- You prefer a solid wood table top without veneer
Verdict: Mitchell 5-Piece Gray Dining Set offers a compact 47-inch round table with padded chairs for small dining areas. It fits buyers who value coordinated gray upholstery and easy single-box shipping over higher seating capacity.
New Classic Amy Counter Dining Set
Best for: small kitchens needing counter-height seating
- Number of Pieces
- 5
- Height Type
- Counter Height
- Table Material
- Mindi, Rubber Wood Solids and Veneers
- Chair Material
- Padded
- Table Dimensions
- 42.25" L x 42.25" W x 36.25" H
- Weight Capacity per Chair
- 250 lbs
View on Amazon: New Classic Amy Counter Dining Set Affiliate link
This New Classic Furniture Amy set includes a round counter-height table and four padded chairs. The table top features reverse diamond match veneer, while the chairs support up to 250 pounds each. The gray finish offers a modern look suitable for various decor styles. With dimensions of 42.25 inches square and 36.25 inches high, it fits standard kitchen spaces. The construction uses Mindi wood, rubber wood solids, and veneers for durability.
Pros
- Counter height design at 36.25 inches
- 250 lbs weight capacity per chair
- Round table shape with diamond match veneer
- Constructed from Mindi and rubber wood solids
Cons
- Requires assembly
- Round shape may not fit narrow alcoves
- Limited color options compared to standard dining sets
Good fit if
- You need counter-height seating for a kitchen island
- You prefer a round table for easier conversation
- You want a gray modern aesthetic
Skip if
- You require standard 30-inch table height
- You need a rectangular table for a dining room
- You prefer solid wood construction without veneers
Verdict: New Classic Amy 5-Piece Counter Set offers a sturdy round counter-height option with high weight capacity. It suits small kitchens needing modern gray styling and durable padded seating.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | New Classic Mitchell 47" Round Dining Set | New Classic Amy Counter Dining Set |
|---|---|---|
| Number of Pieces | 5 | 5 |
| Seating Capacity | 4 | not stated |
| Height Type | not stated | Counter Height |
| Table Material | Mindi wood veneers, solid rubber wood | Mindi, Rubber Wood Solids and Veneers |
| Chair Material | Solid wood, polyester fabric | Padded |
| Backrest Style | Padded | not stated |
| Table Dimensions | 47" diameter x 30.25"H | 42.25" L x 42.25" W x 36.25" H |
| Weight Capacity per Chair | 250 lbs | 250 lbs |
| Table Shape | not stated | Round |
| Color | Grey | Grey |
| Dimensions | 47 × 47 × 30.3 inches | 42 × 42 × 36 inches |
| Weight | 68.3 pounds | 130 pounds |
| Size | 47 inches in diameter and 30.25 inches high | Onesize |
| Model | D1763-50S-GRY | D3651-52S-GRY |
Frequently asked questions
Which set is better for small kitchens?
The Mitchell set is often better for tight spaces because of its smaller footprint. The table measures 47 inches in diameter and weighs 68.3 pounds. This compact size makes it easier to fit into narrower rooms compared to the heavier Amy set.
What is the difference in table height?
The Mitchell table stands at 30.25 inches high, which is standard dining height. The Amy table is taller at 36 inches, designed for counter-height seating. You should choose the Mitchell if you want traditional chair height, or the Amy for bar-style seating.
Do both sets have the same weight capacity?
The data does not specify the weight capacity for the Mitchell set. However, the Amy set is described as having a high weight capacity and weighs 130 pounds total. The Amy set appears more robust due to its significantly higher total weight of 130 pounds versus 68.3 pounds.
Are the chairs padded in both sets?
Yes, both sets feature padded seats for comfort. The Mitchell set includes four padded chairs with gray upholstery. The Amy set also offers modern gray styling with durable padded seating. This shared feature ensures comfortable dining in either configuration.
Which model number should I look for?
The Mitchell set model is D1763-50S-GRY. The Amy set model is D3651-52S-GRY. Both share the GRY suffix for their gray color. Checking these specific model numbers ensures you order the correct set for your needs.
Is the table shape the same for both?
Yes, both dining sets feature a round table shape. The Mitchell table is 47 inches wide and long. The Amy table is slightly smaller at 42 inches wide and long. Both round designs help maximize space in small kitchens.