Looking Beyond the Signature Design by Ashley Caitbrook Counter Height? 6 Alternatives Worth a Look

How each alternative compares

Roundhill Leviton 6-Piece Counter Height Set

The Roundhill Leviton set swaps the Caitbrook’s square profile for a wider rectangular surface measuring 65 inches long. This extra length provides more room for place settings compared to the 60-inch table. However, the chairs sit at 30 inches high, which is lower than the Caitbrook’s 36-inch counter height. You lose the tucked-away storage benefit since standard chairs do not slide under a 36-inch apron as easily. The build relies on solid wood, offering a different tactile feel than the veneer and MDF mix. Choose this if you prefer a traditional dining height and need extra table length for large gatherings.

Roundhill Furniture Sora 3-Piece Grey Counter Set

The Roundhill Sora set is a compact three-piece option designed for two people, not six. It features a small table measuring 41.5 inches long and 22 inches wide, making it suitable for tight corners or breakfast nooks. The stools are counter height at 36 inches, matching the Caitbrook’s table height for proper ergonomics. You give up seating for four other people and lose the sturdy hardwood frame found in the larger set. The total weight is just 50.3 pounds, allowing for easy repositioning. Pick this alternative if you live alone or with one partner and need a minimal footprint that still fits counter-height spaces.

AMERLIFE 7-Piece Farmhouse Dining Set

The AMERLIFE set includes six chairs but uses a 30-inch high table, placing it in the standard dining category rather than counter height. This table is 60 inches long, matching the Caitbrook’s length, but the lower profile changes the seating dynamic. The chairs are likely standard height, meaning they will not slide under the table apron for space saving. The build uses solid wood, which may offer greater durability than the Caitbrook’s veneer construction. The total set weighs 151 pounds, lighter than the Caitbrook’s 194 pounds. Choose this if you prefer traditional dining height and want a farmhouse aesthetic with solid wood materials.

Gizoon 63" Grey Dining Set for 6

The Gizoon 63-inch set offers a longer table surface at 63 inches compared to the Caitbrook’s 60 inches. It uses sliding benches instead of individual chairs, which maximizes floor space in small rooms. The table height is 30 inches, making it a standard dining height rather than counter height. You lose the ability to tuck seating completely under the table, but the benches slide out easily for extra width. The set seats six people comfortably. This option is ideal if you have a narrow room where extending seating outward is more practical than pulling chairs back. The lower height suits those who prefer standard table ergonomics.

Gizoon 63" Grey 7-Piece Dining Set

This Gizoon seven-piece set also features a 30-inch high table, differing from the Caitbrook’s 36-inch counter height. It includes six seats and a table measuring 63 inches long. The design uses solid hardwood, providing a robust build similar to the Caitbrook’s frame. The lower table height means the chairs will not slide under the apron for space saving. This set is better for standard dining rooms where tucked-away seating is less critical. The seven-piece count includes extra components, potentially offering more versatility. Choose this if you want solid wood construction and a longer table but do not require counter-height dimensions.

Ashley Skempton Square Counter Height Set

The Ashley Skempton set uses a square table measuring 42.1 inches on each side, offering a different footprint than the Caitbrook’s rectangular 36x60-inch table. It is also counter height at 36 inches, ensuring compatible seating. However, it seats only four people, reducing capacity by two compared to the Caitbrook. The total weight is 120 pounds, significantly lighter than the 194-pound Caitbrook set. This makes it easier to move in small apartments. The square shape can fit into corners more efficiently. Pick this alternative if you need counter-height seating but have a smaller dining area that cannot accommodate a six-person rectangular table.

Quick picks

Our 7 picks

1 Best overall

Ashley Caitbrook Counter Height Set for 6

Best for: families needing durable counter height seating for six

Seating Capacity

6

Height Type

Counter height

Table Material

Hardwood solids, acacia veneer, MDF

Chair Material

Solid hardwood, polyester

Table Dimensions

36" W x 60" D x 36" H

Color

Grey

View on Amazon: Ashley Caitbrook Counter Height Set for 6 Affiliate link

This Signature Design by Ashley set includes a counter height table and six chairs. The table measures 36 inches wide by 60 inches deep. It uses hardwood solids and acacia veneer. The chairs have solid hardwood frames and gray polyester upholstery. The seats slide under the apron for a clean look. It suits families needing durable seating for daily meals.

Pros

• Seats six people comfortably
• Hardwood solids and acacia veneer construction
• Chairs slide under the 32.25-inch apron
• Plush cushioned seats with nailhead accents

Cons

• 194-pound weight makes moving difficult
• MDF substrate may be less durable than solid wood
• 45-minute assembly time required

Good fit if

• You need seating for six people
• You want a counter height table that fits standard chairs
• You prefer a modern gray finish

Skip if

• You have limited space for a 60-inch table
• You prefer a lower table height
• You want a lightweight set for frequent rearranging

Verdict: Signature Caitbrook 6-Piece Counter Height Set offers ample seating and sturdy materials for larger families. It fits homes where a substantial table anchors the dining area.

2 Best premium

Roundhill Leviton 6-Piece Counter Height Set

Best for: families needing six-person counter height seating

Seating Capacity

6

Height Type

counter height

Table Material

solid wood

Chair Material

solid wood

Backrest Style

button tufted back

Table Dimensions

65W x 38D x 30H in

View on Amazon: Roundhill Leviton 6-Piece Counter Height Set Affiliate link

This Roundhill Leviton set includes a table and six chairs in a grey finish. The table measures 65 inches wide by 38 inches deep, offering ample surface area for your meals. Each chair stands 39.2 inches tall with a 19-inch seat height, matching standard counter heights. The solid wood construction provides a durable base for your dining room. The button-tufted backs add a touch of traditional style to the functional design.

Pros

• Includes six chairs for larger gatherings
• Solid wood construction for durability
• Button-tufted backrests for comfort
• Generous 65-inch table width

Cons

• Heavy at 198 pounds
• Requires assembly
• Ships in multiple boxes

Good fit if

• You need seating for six people
• You prefer traditional turned-leg styles
• You want solid wood materials

Skip if

• You need a compact table under 60 inches
• You want a ready-to-use item without assembly
• You prefer a single-box delivery

Verdict: Roundhill Leviton 6-Piece Grey Dining Set fits households that need extra seating and traditional styling. Its solid wood build and wide table surface support regular family dinners.

3 Also great

Roundhill Furniture Sora 3-Piece Grey Counter Set

Best for: Small spaces and couples

Number of Pieces

3

Height Type

Counter Height

Table Material

MDF, solid rubberwood

Chair Material

Solid rubberwood, fabric

Backrest Style

Button tufted saddle

Table Dimensions

41.5"W x 22"D x 36"H

View on Amazon: Roundhill Furniture Sora 3-Piece Grey Counter Set Affiliate link

This Roundhill Sora set includes one table and two stools. The table measures 41.5 inches wide by 22 inches deep, with a 36-inch height. It features an MDF top with rubberwood legs. The stools have button-tufted fabric seats and rubberwood frames. This compact arrangement suits small kitchens or breakfast nooks where space is limited.

Pros

• Includes two matching upholstered stools
• Solid rubberwood legs for stability
• Compact 41.5-inch table width
• Button-tufted saddle seat design

Cons

• Only three pieces total
• MDF table top is less durable than solid wood
• Limited seating for more than two people

Good fit if

• You need a compact dining solution for two
• You prefer upholstered stools for comfort
• You have a small kitchen or breakfast nook

Skip if

• You need to seat four or more people regularly
• You require a solid wood table top
• You want a full six-piece dining set

Verdict: Roundhill Sora 3-Piece Grey Counter Set offers a cozy spot for two with its upholstered stools and compact table. It fits small spaces well but lacks capacity for larger families.

4 Best farmhouse

AMERLIFE 7-Piece Farmhouse Dining Set

Best for: small dining rooms needing six seats

Number of Pieces

7

Seating Capacity

6

Table Shape

Rectangular

Table Material

Solid wood

Chair Material

Linen fabric

Backrest Style

Curved back

View on Amazon: AMERLIFE 7-Piece Farmhouse Dining Set Affiliate link

This AMERLIFE set offers a 60-inch rectangular solid wood table with six upholstered linen chairs. The 300 lbs weight capacity per chair supports daily use. The grey and white farmhouse design fits compact dining rooms or apartments. Chairs tuck under the 30-inch high table for space savings. It includes labeled parts for easy assembly. This set suits those seeking a durable, space-efficient option for six people.

Pros

• Solid wood construction for durability
• 300 lbs weight capacity per chair
• Upholstered linen fabric cushions
• Space-saving design with tuck-under chairs
• Easy assembly with labeled parts

Cons

• Rectangular shape may not fit round dining areas
• Fabric seats require spot cleaning only
• Limited color options compared to other styles

Good fit if

• You need seating for six people
• You have a compact dining area
• You prefer a farmhouse style

Skip if

• You require a round table shape
• You want a higher counter height
• You need a larger seating capacity

Verdict: AMERLIFE 7-Piece Farmhouse Dining Set provides a sturdy, space-efficient solution for families of six. Its solid wood build and comfortable chairs make it ideal for small dining rooms or apartments.

5 Best budget

Gizoon 63" Grey Dining Set for 6

Best for: small spaces needing flexible seating for six

Number of Pieces

5

Seating Capacity

6

Table Material

MDF, metal

Table Dimensions

63" x 30" x 30"

Weight Capacity per Chair

550 lbs

Color

Grey

View on Amazon: Gizoon 63" Grey Dining Set for 6 Affiliate link

This set seats six with a 63-inch table, two benches, and two stools. The benches slide under the table to save space in smaller rooms. Each seat supports 550 lbs, and the table holds 220 lbs. The MDF top and metal frame offer scratch resistance. Adjustable feet and silicone edge covers add stability and safety for everyday use.

Pros

• Seats six people comfortably with benches and stools
• Benches slide under the table for space saving
• 550 lbs weight capacity per bench and stool
• Includes silicone edge covers for safety
• Adjustable feet for stability on uneven surfaces

Cons

• Table weight capacity is lower at 220 lbs
• MDF material may be less durable than solid wood
• Benches lack back support for long-term seating

Good fit if

• You need seating for six in a compact area
• You want benches that tuck away to clear floor space
• You prioritize high weight capacity for durability

Skip if

• You prefer solid wood construction over MDF
• You need individual chairs with back support
• You require a table weight capacity above 220 lbs

Verdict: Gizoon 63" Grey Dining Set for 6 fits small households needing flexible seating. The sliding benches maximize floor space while the high weight limits ensure sturdy daily use.

6 Best faux leather

Gizoon 63" Grey 7-Piece Dining Set

Best for: Compact dining areas needing six seats

Number of Pieces

7

Seating Capacity

6

Table Shape

Rectangular

Table Material

Solid hardwood, steel frame

Chair Material

PU leather

Table Dimensions

63" L x 29.9" W x 29.9" H

View on Amazon: Gizoon 63" Grey 7-Piece Dining Set Affiliate link

This Gizoon dining set includes a 63-inch rectangular table and six chairs. The table uses solid hardwood and steel, while the chairs feature PU leather and foam cushions. It seats six people comfortably. The chairs tuck under the table to save space. This set suits apartments or compact dining areas where you need durable, modern furniture that is easy to clean.

Pros

• Seats six people
• Solid hardwood table top
• Steel frame for stability
• Chairs tuck under table
• PU leather upholstery

Cons

• Counter height may be too high for some
• No bench included
• Chairs lack armrests

Good fit if

• You need seating for six
• You have a compact dining area
• You prefer a rectangular table

Skip if

• You need a round table
• You require a standard height table
• You want a bench included

Verdict: Gizoon 7-Piece Grey Counter Height Set offers solid hardwood durability and space-saving design for families of six. It fits well in apartments where tucking chairs under the table is essential.

7 Best 4

Ashley Skempton Square Counter Height Set

Best for: small apartments and breakfast nooks

Number of Pieces

5

Seating Capacity

4

Table Shape

square

Height Type

counter height

Table Material

wood, veneer, engineered wood

Chair Material

polyester fabric, wood, veneer

View on Amazon: Ashley Skempton Square Counter Height Set Affiliate link

This five-piece dining set features a square table measuring 42.13 inches wide and deep. It includes four ladderback stools with cushioned polyester seats. The counter height design fits apartments and breakfast nooks. The charcoal gray finish suits modern decor. You get a compact footprint for small spaces. The set seats four people comfortably. Assembly requires a helper and clear instructions.

Pros

• Square 42.13-inch table saves corner space
• Counter height 36-inch profile
• Cushioned ladderback stools for comfort
• Seats four people
• Textured gray polyester upholstery

Cons

• Limited to four seats
• Heavy at 120 pounds
• Requires assembly with a helper

Good fit if

• You need a square table for tight corners
• You want counter height seating
• You prefer a compact four-seat setup

Skip if

• You need seating for more than four people
• You require a rectangular table shape
• You want a pre-assembled unit

Verdict: Signature Design by Ashley 42" Square Counter Height Set offers a space-saving square design for small apartments. It suits you if you need compact counter-height seating for four.

Specifications side by side

Frequently asked questions

See also

• best signature design by ashley mattresses
• best signature design by ashley recliners