Signature Design by Ashley Haddigan Dining Extension Table vs Signature Design by Ashley Extendable Round to Oval (2026): Key Differences
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links on this page are affiliate links.
This comparison looks at the signature design by ashley haddigan dining extension table vs the Signature Design by Ashley Extendable Round to Oval. Both are standard dining height tables from the same brand, designed for six guests. They share a common need for assembly and include necessary hardware. The main difference lies in their shape and material construction. One offers a rectangular farmhouse profile with a butterfly leaf, while the other transforms from round to oval using a drop-in leaf.
Key differences
| Aspect | Signature Design by Ashley Haddigan Dining Extension Table | Ashley Round to Oval Extendable Dining Table |
|---|---|---|
| Table Shape | Rectangular | Round to Oval |
| Seating Capacity | 6-8 | 6 |
| Tabletop Material | Select oak veneer and hardwood solids | Veneers, wood and engineered wood |
| Style | Farmhouse | French country-inspired |
| Color | Dark Brown | Whitewash |
| Overall Width | 78.13 in | 72 in |
Which one should you choose?
Choose Signature Design by Ashley Haddigan Dining Extension Table if
- You need a rectangular table that seats up to eight people when extended.
- You prefer a dark brown farmhouse aesthetic with solid hardwood accents.
- You want a wider surface area for larger gatherings.
Choose Ashley Round to Oval Extendable Dining Table if
- You want a versatile table that starts as a compact round shape.
- You prefer a lighter whitewash finish that fits a French country style.
- You need a lighter table that weighs less for easier moving.
Verdict: Choose the Haddigan model if you prioritize a larger seating capacity and a traditional rectangular footprint. The Round to Oval option is better if you need space flexibility with a round base and a lighter, brighter finish.
Haddigan vs Round to Oval
Seating Capacity
The Signature Design by Ashley Haddigan Dining Extension Table accommodates six to eight people when the butterfly leaf is extended. This flexibility allows you to host larger gatherings comfortably. In contrast, the Signature Design by Ashley Extendable Round to Oval Table is rated for six guests. While the Haddigan offers extra capacity, the Round to Oval provides consistent seating for standard family dinners without needing to adjust expectations for larger crowds.
Table Shape
Shape dictates how you arrange chairs and move around the room. The Haddigan is a rectangular extension table measuring 78.13 inches wide by 42 inches deep. This linear form suits traditional dining rooms with clear traffic lanes. The Round to Oval Table starts as a round surface and transforms into an oval. This unique shape creates a more intimate dining atmosphere and eliminates sharp corners, making it a safer choice for homes with young children or tight kitchen layouts.
Material
Build materials influence durability and aesthetic. The Haddigan uses select oak veneer and hardwood solids for its tabletop. Hardwood solids generally offer greater structural integrity and resistance to wear over time. The Round to Oval Table combines veneers, wood, and engineered wood. Engineered wood can be less stable than solid hardwoods under heavy loads or humidity changes. If you prioritize long-term sturdiness and natural wood feel, the Haddigan’s hardwood construction is the stronger option.
Style
Visual design must match your existing decor. The Haddigan features a farmhouse profile with a dry smoky dark brown oak finish and a worn effect on edges. This creates a rustic, casual look. The Round to Oval Table offers a French country-inspired style with a whitewash finish and natural oak tone top. The chipped white finish provides a lighter, airy aesthetic. Choose the Haddigan for dark, rustic warmth, or the Round to Oval for bright, coastal or cottage vibes.
Weight
Weight affects moving and stability. The Haddigan Table weighs 121 pounds. The heavier mass suggests a solid, stable piece that is less likely to wobble during use. The Round to Oval Table weighs 101 pounds. The lighter weight makes it easier to reposition or move during cleaning. However, the Haddigan’s additional 20 pounds likely contribute to its heavier-duty hardwood construction, offering a more robust feel during daily meals.
Choose Your Ashley Table
Hosts needing flexible seating
The Haddigan table seats six to eight people when you use the built-in butterfly leaf. Its rectangular shape measures 78.13 inches wide by 42 inches deep. This layout offers more linear space for guests. You can accommodate larger groups comfortably compared to round designs. The hardwood solids and oak veneer provide a sturdy base for heavy gatherings.
Small space kitchen owners
This round table transforms into an oval with a drop-in leaf. It measures 72 inches wide by 48.3 inches deep. The round shape fits better in tight corners or bistro settings. You save floor space when not extended. The whitewash finish adds a light, airy feel to compact dining areas. It is also lighter at 101 pounds.
Farmhouse style enthusiasts
The Haddigan features a straightforward farmhouse profile with a dark brown oak finish. It has rounded, worn edges for a casual look. The classic styling suits traditional dining rooms. You get a sophisticated yet rustic appearance. The solid hardwood base supports the table's weight of 121 pounds, ensuring stability.
French country decor fans
This table showcases a French country-inspired style with a chipped white finish. The natural oak tone top contrasts nicely with the whitewash. You get a vintage aesthetic without the heavy weight. The engineered wood and veneer construction keeps it manageable. It is an ideal choice for cottage or bistro themes.
The products compared
Signature Design by Ashley Haddigan Dining Extension Table
Best for: flexible seating for six to eight people
- Seating Capacity
- 6-8
- Overall Width
- 78.3 in
- Overall Depth
- 42 in
- Overall Height
- 30.25 in
- Material
- Wood
- Style
- Farmhouse
View on Amazon: Signature Design by Ashley Haddigan Dining Extension Table Affiliate link
This Signature Design by Ashley Haddigan dining table seats six to eight people. It features a butterfly leaf extension that increases depth from 63 inches to 78.13 inches. The tabletop uses select oak veneer and hardwood solids. The finish is a dark brown oak with a worn effect. You get standard 30.25-inch height for comfortable seating. Assembly is required with included tools.
Pros
- Butterfly leaf extension expands seating from six to eight
- Constructed with select oak veneer and hardwood solids
- Standard 30.25-inch height fits most dining chairs
- Rounded edges provide a casual farmhouse look
Cons
- Heavier at 121 pounds, making it difficult to move
- Requires assembly, which takes time and effort
- Dining chairs are sold separately
Good fit if
- You need flexible seating for occasional larger gatherings
- You prefer a solid wood construction with a worn finish
- You want a standard height table for your existing chairs
Skip if
- You need a table that arrives fully assembled
- You want a smaller footprint for a tight space
- You prefer a smooth, modern surface without a worn effect
Verdict: Signature Haddigan 78 in Extension Table offers reliable capacity for eight people through its butterfly leaf. It suits you if you prioritize solid wood durability and flexible seating over easy mobility.
Ashley Round to Oval Extendable Dining Table
Best for: Small dining areas needing flexible seating
- Seating Capacity
- 4 to 6
- Table Shape
- Round to oval
- Overall Width
- 72 inches
- Overall Depth
- 48.3 inches
- Overall Height
- 30.3 inches
- Material
- Wood
View on Amazon: Ashley Round to Oval Extendable Dining Table Affiliate link
This Signature Design by Ashley dining table transforms from a 48-inch round shape to a 72-inch oval. It seats six people comfortably. The tabletop uses veneers, wood, and engineered wood with a whitewash finish. You extend it by pulling both ends and dropping in a separate leaf. It stands at standard dining height. This setup works well for casual dining spaces that need flexible seating.
Pros
- Extends from 48 to 72 inches
- Seats six people
- Standard 30-inch height
- Separate drop-in leaf included
Cons
- Requires assembly
- Heavier build at 101 pounds
- Limited to six seats
Good fit if
- You need to seat six guests
- You want a round table that expands
- You prefer a whitewash finish
Skip if
- You need seating for eight or more
- You want a pre-assembled table
- You prefer a dark wood tone
Verdict: Signature Design by Ashley Extendable Round to Oval Table offers a practical way to gain extra space. It fits you if you need six seats and a convertible shape.
Specifications side by side
| Spec | Signature Design by Ashley Haddigan Dining Extension Table | Ashley Round to Oval Extendable Dining Table |
|---|---|---|
| Seating Capacity | 6-8 | 4 to 6 |
| Table Shape | not stated | Round to oval |
| Overall Width | 78.3 in | 72 inches |
| Overall Depth | 42 in | 48.3 inches |
| Overall Height | 30.25 in | 30.3 inches |
| Material | Wood | Wood |
| Extendable | not stated | Extendable |
| Style | Farmhouse | not stated |
| Use | Kitchen | not stated |
| Dimensions | 42 × 78.3 × 30.3 inches | 48.3 × 72 × 30.3 inches |
| Weight | 121 pounds | 101 pounds |
| Size | 78.13" W x 42" D x 30.25" H | 0 |
| Color | Dark Brown | Whitewash |
| Model | D596-35 | D743-35 |
Frequently asked questions
What is the exact weight difference between the Haddigan table and the Round to Oval model?
The Haddigan table weighs 121 pounds, while the Round to Oval model weighs 101 pounds. This 20-pound difference makes the Round to Oval option lighter and potentially easier to move. You should consider this if you plan to rearrange your dining area frequently. The heavier Haddigan offers more stability due to its solid wood construction.
How do the dimensions of the Haddigan table compare to the Round to Oval table?
The Haddigan measures 78.13 inches wide by 42 inches deep. The Round to Oval table is 72 inches wide by 48.3 inches deep. Both share the same height of 30.3 inches. The Haddigan is wider but shallower, while the Round to Oval is narrower but deeper. Choose based on your room's shape.
Does the Haddigan table come in a whitewash finish like the other model?
No, the Haddigan table is available in Dark Brown. The Round to Oval model comes in a Whitewash finish. If you prefer a lighter, coastal look, the Round to Oval is the better choice. The Haddigan offers a traditional Farmhouse style with its darker wood tone.
Which table is better for small dining areas requiring flexible seating?
The Round to Oval table is specifically noted as best for small dining areas needing flexible seating. Its ability to convert from round to oval saves space when not in use. The Haddigan requires more floor space due to its rectangular shape and butterfly leaf extension. It suits larger rooms better.
What is the model number for the Signature Design by Ashley Haddigan table?
The model number for the Haddigan table is D596-35. The Round to Oval model uses model number D743-35. You can use these numbers to verify product details or find replacement parts. They help distinguish between the two similar Ashley products.
Is the Haddigan table suitable for hosting eight people comfortably?
Yes, the Haddigan table accommodates up to eight people when the butterfly leaf is extended. It provides reliable capacity for larger gatherings. The Round to Oval table seats six people. If you regularly host large groups, the Haddigan offers the necessary extra seating space.
Do both tables share the same standard dining height?
Yes, both tables stand at 30.3 inches high. This is the standard height for most dining chairs. You do not need to adjust your existing chairs for either option. The consistent height ensures compatibility with standard dining room furniture.